After reading chapters 20 to 22, you can start to clearly
see the transition in focus of the novel. Initially the novel tends to focus on
the conflict between Hester and society, including the conflict between Hester
and Chillingworth. The novel then transitions to focus on Dimmesdale’s struggle
with society and Chillingworth. Finally, the novel now looks to the conflict
between Dimmesdale and Hester’s love and the expectations of society. In these chapters, Dimmesdale and Hester meet
in the woods, the domain of sin and the devil, to plan their course of action.
They decide to take a ship back to England to lead a happy life. Pearl is also
introduced to her father, Dimmesdale. When Pearl first sees him, she thinks
that he is the Black Man, or the devil. Dimmesdale is elated by this decision
and has the urge to show his sudden change in mood as he returns to his
lodging. He actually shows this change in mood to an elderly lady, which he
later recognizes as a poor decision.
Dimmesdale can be related to Romeo from Romeo and Juliet
when he first declares his love. Dimmesdale, much like Romeo, is overjoyed and believes
that he is about to begin a successful chapter of his life. This plan however is
foiled by an enemy of the relationship; in this case it is Chillingworth. Chillingworth
foiled this by boarding the ship to England also.
I disagree with your connection of Dimmesdale to Romeo. Dimmesdale regrets his actions after and does not try to be a part of Hester's life and fears that God will judge him while Romeo continued to miss Juliet and tried to get back together with her.
ReplyDeleteI liked how you commented on the connection between the meeting place of Hester and Dimmesdale, as it does hold value. They both sinned, and therefore the only place they can meet up without being further scrutinized is the forest, a dark place inherent with evil. They meet up in the place of sin and evil, which you so nicely referenced, and make plans to commit more sin. The sin this time is simply wanting to be rid of Puritan Society and the blemishes it has caused in their name, which in reality isn't a sin at all.
ReplyDeleteI also disagree with your connection because I do not think it was Chillingworth that ruined the relationship between but their society and beliefs in society. They initially cannot be together because of society and that is what ruins their relationship. Even once they plan to move away, I think Dimmesdale would feel so guilty about sinning and going against society again that it may lead to self destruction or destruction of the relationship regardless of if Chillingworth came along or not. However, I can see your thought process and I understand your view and where you made that connection. I would've enjoyed reading more of your reaction to the chapters as opposed to plot summary.
ReplyDeleteI like your thread to romeo and juliet, and within the context of the point you are trying to prove it is perfect. Dimmesdale however is the opposite of juliet and he refuses to admit his love for her openly.
ReplyDelete